The Longest Lasting Protection
Log homes present a unique set of dynamics to an exterior finish system. As opposed to dimensional lumber, logs experience much more expansion and contraction, typically retain more moisture and on round logs, the upper surfaces weather more rapidly than the lower ones due to increased ultraviolet (UV) light exposure. Low cost, general purpose exterior wood finishes are designed to be applied on well seasoned or kiln dried dimensional lumber and plywood and are unable to cope with parameters presented by log homes.
A quality log home finish must:
- Prevent liquid water from entering the wood.
- Breathe in order to allow water vapor to escape from the wood. This is especially important if the logs are somewhat green or checks have developed that have allowed water entry into the wood.
- Be flexible in order to stretch and contract without cracking.
- Prevent the formation of unsightly mold on the surface.
- Protect the underlying wood from degrading due to ultraviolet (UV) light.
- Withstand temperatures ranging from arctic cold to tropical heat.
- Be durable enough to withstand abrasion from wind, rain, snow, ice, etc.
- Be easy to apply.
- Look beautiful and maintain its appearance for many years.
- Another factor to consider in this day and age is that any and all products should be kind to our environment.
When it comes to stains, one or two coat oil-based stains are at the bottom of the quality ladder. They are cheap to produce and are fairly inexpensive. They are often presented as “penetrating” stains but since they do penetrate into the wood to some extent, they leave the surface without much protection. That’s why most manufacturers recommend additional coats every year or two. In addition, many oil-based products contain linseed oil, a wonderful food source for mold that turns the surface black over time. They also have low coverage rates, typically 150 to 200 square feet per gallon. They may be cheap but it takes a lot of product to stain a home.
A step up on the ladder are film-forming solvent-based finishes but their quality and cost can range from moderate to high. Like all oil/solvent-based systems, these products are suffering the consequences of Federal and State requirements for lower VOC (volatile organic content) levels and manufacturers are subsequently reducing the solvent content with a corresponding decrease in performance. Some of the better products are no longer allowed to be sold in several states in the northeast and California. The biggest problem with these products is their inability to breathe and it is not unusual to see sheets of finish come off a wall due to water vapor trying to escape from the wood.
Over the past few years almost all newly developed coating technology has been in water-based systems allowing the formulation of high quality products that meet all of the requirements listed above. Recent advances in polymers, UV light inhibitors and mildewcides have significantly improved the look and performance of water-based coating systems. However, for those manufacturers willing to make the investment this new technology is not cheap and these new systems are costly. The one factor that alleviates the cost per gallon is their ability to be applied at application rates ranging from 350 to 600 square feet per gallon, quite high in comparison to oil-based products. Since water-based stains are film formers, they provide protection where it is needed the most, on the surface of the wood.
In addition to the actual stain, clear topcoats have become an integral part of a quality finish system. Although clear topcoats have been used over log home stains for a number of years, recent advances in polymer technology have led to the development of new topcoat systems like Lifeline™ Advance Gloss and Satin that not only appreciably extend the life of the stain but do much, much more. First of all they significantly improve the look of the finish by enhancing its color, clarity and depth. The second thing is their ability to keep the surface extremely clean. Lifeline Advance is designed to form a hard breathable film that is much more resistant to dirt pick-up. In addition, the hard smooth surface makes it quite easy to clean off any dust or pollen that may accumulate on the surface of the logs.
Another feature provided by a hard smooth topcoat is greater resistance to mold, mildew and algae growth. In addition to water these organisms need something to grip onto. If the spores land on a hard smooth surface that rapidly sheds water, they won’t have an opportunity to germinate and spread. So the surface of the logs stays free of unsightly mold spots and patches of algae.
Of course the best feature of clear topcoats is the protection they provide to the color containing stain. Car coating experts discovered the benefits imparted by clear topcoats many years ago. Today’s car finishes remain shiny and last longer than ever thought possible all due to the application of a clear topcoat. This same concept and technology went into the formulation of Lifeline Advance Gloss and Satin topcoats for log and timber homes. They help prevent the color stain from degrading by protecting the entire finish system from dirt, wind, water and sunlight.
The bottom line is that a low cost, low quality stain may end up costing almost as much as a high quality finish system for the initial application (differences in coverage rate) and will last perhaps a year or two. In addition, once a low quality stain fails the wood will quickly gray and unless the home is thoroughly cleaned, the gray will show through any subsequent coats of stain that are applied.
The cost per gallon of a high quality finish system may be twice that of a low quality product but the higher coverage rate will probably make up most of the difference in total product cost. A high quality system will last at least five years and probably many more depending on environmental conditions. And since high quality finish systems are much more efficient in preventing graying do to UV light, a simple wash-down is typically sufficient to prepare the surface for a maintenance coat of stain and or topcoat.
In addition to actual product cost, one has to also consider the cost of application which is typically three or four times the cost of the product itself. Over a 20 year span, the use of an inexpensive exterior finish can end up costing a homeowner many thousands of dollars more than if he or she had used a quality product in the first place.
Here are some numbers to look at
[LQ=low quality, HQ=high quality]
In reality the HQ numbers are quite conservative in that the finish will probably last longer than 5 years before it needs a maintenance coat and the average application rate is at the low end of the scale. Typically the second, third and maintenance coats average between 600 to 800 sq. ft. per gallon.
Typical 2400 sq. ft. home
Two coat, low quality stain @ $37.50 per gallon.
LQ, initial product cost = $900 (avg. application rate of 200 sq. ft. per gallon)
LQ, application cost = $2,700
Every 2 years, one coat
LQ, maintenance coat = $500
LQ, application cost = $1,500
Over 20 years
LQ, product cost = $5,900
LQ, application cost = $17,700
Total $23,600
Three coat, high quality finish system. Two coats of stain, one coat of topcoat @ $72.73 per gallon.
HQ, initial product cost = $1,200 (avg. application rate of 436 sq. ft. per gallon)
HQ, application cost = $3,600
Every 5 years, one coat
HQ, maintenance coat = $500
HQ, application cost = $1,500
Over 20 years
HQ, product cost = $3,200
HQ, application cost = $7,200
Total $10,400
Savings over 20 years not counting inflation, $13,200